Every church tech stack starts with rational decisions. A website here, a ChMS there, a giving platform to round it out. Each tool solved a real problem at the time.
But stack enough rational decisions on top of each other, and you end up with a patchwork of disconnected software that’s quietly draining your budget, your team’s energy, and your ministry’s effectiveness.
Here’s the hard truth: most churches are running 5 to 8 separate software tools for basic digital ministry functions. A website here, a church management system there, a giving platform over there, plus video hosting, email marketing, a mobile app, event registration—each with its own login, its own monthly bill, and its own learning curve.
These five signs indicate it’s time to stop adding tools and start consolidating your church software into something that actually works together.
Sign 1: Your Team Juggles More Logins Than They Can Remember
Here’s a quick test. Ask your communications director how many different platforms they log into during a typical week.
If the answer is more than three, that’s a consolidation signal.
Most church staff and volunteers interact with a scattered collection of tools every single week:
- Church management system (Planning Center, Breeze, or similar) for people and groups
- Website CMS (WordPress, Squarespace, Wix) for content updates
- Email platform (Mailchimp, Constant Contact) for newsletters
- Giving platform (Tithe.ly, Pushpay) for donation management
- Video hosting (Vimeo, YouTube) for sermons
- Social media tools for scheduling and posting
- Communication apps (Slack, GroupMe, texting platforms) for team coordination
That’s seven platforms before you even count event registration, volunteer scheduling, or background check services.
Each login isn’t just a password to remember. It’s a separate interface to learn, a separate support team to contact when something breaks, and a separate set of data that doesn’t automatically sync with everything else. Research from Zylo’s 2025 SaaS Management Index found that organizations only actively use about 47% of their software licenses—meaning roughly half of what you’re paying for is underutilized or forgotten entirely.
The ministry cost: Your team spends mental energy navigating tools instead of serving people. Every minute spent hunting for the right login or figuring out which platform has the information they need is a minute they’re not spending on discipleship, pastoral care, or creative ministry work.
Sign 2: You’re Entering the Same Information in Multiple Places
This is the one that quietly drives church administrators insane.
A new family visits your church on Sunday. Someone enters their information into the church management system. Then the communications director adds their email to Mailchimp so they get the welcome sequence. Then the children’s ministry coordinator adds the kids to the check-in system. Then someone updates the website’s member directory.
One family. Four systems. Four data entry points. Four chances for a misspelled name, a wrong email address, or a missed entry.
Now multiply that by every new visitor, every address change, every updated phone number, every ministry signup throughout the year. You’re not just duplicating work—you’re creating an environment where errors are inevitable and no single system has the complete, accurate picture.
This is what “data silos” look like in a church context. Your information is trapped in separate systems that don’t talk to each other. The giving platform knows who donated last month, but your church management software doesn’t. Your email tool knows who opened the newsletter, but your people database doesn’t. Your event registration tool knows who signed up for the men’s retreat, but nobody else does—unless someone manually exports a spreadsheet and imports it somewhere else.
The ministry cost: When your data lives in silos, you can’t truly know your people. You can’t see the full picture of someone’s engagement—their attendance, their giving, their group involvement, their volunteer service—in one place. That means pastoral care gets harder, follow-up falls through the cracks, and people slip through the gaps between your systems.
Sign 3: Nobody on Staff Can List Every Tech Subscription You’re Paying For
Try this exercise at your next staff meeting: ask everyone to write down every software tool or subscription the church pays for. Collect the lists.
The combined list is almost always longer than any individual’s — and typically surfaces a few subscriptions nobody had on their radar.
This is what happens when church tech decisions get made in silos, too. The worship leader signs up for a streaming tool. The youth pastor subscribes to a curriculum platform. The office manager sets up a scheduling tool. The communications team adds a design subscription. Each one is reasonable. None of them are coordinated.
As we covered in our post on church tech costs, the typical church is spending $150 to $300+ per month across these scattered subscriptions—that’s $2,000 to $5,000+ per year that’s rarely visible on a single budget line.
But the dollar amount is only part of the problem. The bigger issue is feature overlap. You might be paying for email functionality in your church management system AND in a standalone email platform. You might have event registration built into your website tool AND into your ChMS AND through a separate service like Eventbrite. You might be paying for communication features in three different platforms that all do roughly the same thing.
The ministry cost: Poor stewardship isn’t just about overspending. It’s about not knowing what you’re spending. When nobody has visibility into the full church tech stack, there’s no way to make strategic decisions about where to invest—and where to cut. Those hidden dollars could fund a ministry initiative, support a missionary, or hire part-time help for an area that’s stretched thin.
Sign 4: Simple Questions Require Manual Workarounds
Here’s a scenario that plays out in churches every week:
Your pastor asks, “How many first-time visitors from the last three months have joined a small group?”
Reasonable question. Should be simple to answer. But here’s what actually happens:
- Pull the visitor list from your church management system
- Export it to a spreadsheet
- Pull the small group roster from… where? A different module? A separate system? A shared Google Doc?
- Cross-reference the two lists manually
- Hope both lists are up to date (they usually aren’t)
- Deliver an answer 45 minutes later that you’re only moderately confident in
Or this one: “Can you send a thank-you email to everyone who gave to the building fund last quarter, but only if they’re not already in a giving follow-up sequence?”
That requires pulling data from your giving platform, cross-referencing it against your email platform’s automation sequences, building a custom list, and sending—manually stitching together information from systems that were never designed to work together.
When your church tech is integrated, these are two-minute tasks. When it’s fragmented, they’re half-day projects.
The ministry cost: When getting answers requires manual workarounds, one of two things happens. Either your team burns hours doing data gymnastics that should be automated—or they stop asking the questions altogether. And when leaders stop asking questions about engagement, follow-up, and discipleship because the data is too hard to get, the ministry suffers. Not because people don’t care, but because the tools make caring harder than it needs to be.
Sign 5: Onboarding a New Volunteer Takes Weeks Instead of Days
The final sign is one that reveals itself every time someone new joins your team.
A new volunteer steps up to help with communications. Great! Now you need to:
- Create accounts on the church management system
- Grant access to the website backend
- Add them to the email marketing platform
- Share login credentials for the social media scheduler
- Set up their permissions on the giving platform (view only)
- Walk them through how each tool works independently
- Explain the manual processes that connect everything together (“After you update the event on the website, you also need to update it in Planning Center, and then send an email through Mailchimp…”)
Two weeks later, the volunteer is still asking which platform to use for what. A month later, they’ve memorized the workarounds but quietly wonder why church tech has to be this complicated.
Contrast that with a consolidated platform: one account, one login, one interface, one training session. Update an event once—it’s live everywhere. The volunteer is productive in days, not weeks.
According to Zylo’s research, the average organization adds six new software applications every single month. For churches operating with lean staffs and volunteer teams, every additional tool adds friction that makes it harder—not easier—to serve.
The ministry cost: Volunteer retention is one of the biggest challenges in church ministry. When the tools are frustrating, confusing, or time-consuming, you’re not just losing efficiency. You’re losing people. Nobody volunteers at church to fight with software. They volunteer to make a difference. Every unnecessary layer of complexity pushes good-hearted people closer to burnout and further from the work they signed up to do.
The Common Thread: Fragmentation Is the Problem
If two or more of these signs describe your church, the pattern is clear — and it points to a structural issue, not a series of bad calls.
But the pattern reveals something important: the problem isn’t any individual tool. The problem is fragmentation itself.
When your church website, your people database, your communications, your giving, and your media all live in separate systems, the gaps between those systems become the biggest drain on your ministry’s time, money, and energy.
Church tech integration isn’t just a nice-to-have. For growing churches navigating tighter budgets and leaner teams, it’s becoming a necessity.
What Consolidation Actually Looks Like
Consolidating your church tech stack doesn’t mean finding one tool that does everything poorly. It means finding an integrated platform where the core functions of digital ministry—your website, your people management, your communications, your media—are built to work together from the ground up.
That means:
- One source of truth for your people data—no more duplicate entries, no more conflicting records
- One login for your team—less friction, faster onboarding, happier volunteers
- One bill you can actually budget for—transparent costs, no hidden fees across a dozen vendors
- Information that flows between your website, your database, and your communications automatically
- Ownership and control over your digital presence—your church’s data on your church’s domain
How Healthy Is Your Church Tech Stack?
The Church Tech Health Assessment gives you a clear diagnostic.
A quick interactive quiz covering your tools, workflows, costs, and team experience. You’ll get a personalized snapshot of where your tech stack is strong, where it’s costing you, and what your next move should be.
👉 Take the Church Tech Health Assessment — 5 minutes to a clear picture.
Your Technology Should Serve Your Mission
Here’s what it comes down to: your church didn’t start so you could manage software. You exist to make disciples, serve your community, and point people to Jesus.
Your tech stack should make that work easier, not harder. It should free up your team’s time, not consume it. It should bring clarity, not confusion.
If the signs in this post sound like your church, consolidation isn’t just a smart move—it’s a stewardship decision. Every hour your staff spends on manual workarounds, every dollar you spend on overlapping subscriptions, every volunteer you lose to tool fatigue—those are ministry resources that could be invested somewhere that matters.
One platform. One login. One source of truth. Your church deserves technology that works as hard as your team does.
About Digital Church
Digital Church is a unified, self-hosted platform that brings your church website, people management, media, and communications under one roof. We help churches reclaim control of their digital presence—without the complexity, fragmentation, or vendor lock-in of traditional church tech.
Learn more at digitalchurch.com, or book a demo to see it in action.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.